Little snowmobiles can be big polluters in the Arctic.

Jun 24, 2009

Reimann, S, R Kallenborn and N Schmidbauer. 2009. Severe aromatic hydrocarbon pollution in the Arctic town of Longyearbyen (Svalbard) caused by snowmobile emissions. Environmental Science & Technology. doi:10.1021/es900449x.



Synopsis by Wendy Hessler and Paul Eubig, DVM

 

2009-0618snowmobiles
timo_w2s, Flikr.
 

 

Air pollution in a remote Arctic community in Norway approaches levels seen in larger European towns due to the springtime use of snowmobiles. The pollution – specifically, chemicals called aromatic hydrocarbons – is 100 times higher during the spring snowmobile season than during the summer when only cars and large coal trucks are used in the remote area. Older snowmobiles with outdated, 2-stroke engines contribute the most to the excessive levels in the spring. Aromatic hydrocarbons result from incomplete fossil fuel combustion in vehicle engines.

 

 

Context

Longyearbyen, Norway, is a remote community in the Arctic Circle. It has a population of around 2,200 residents, which modestly swells to about 3,000 during the tourist season. The area's main economic activities are tourism, coal mining and scientific research.

One of the prime tourist activities in the spring involves guided snowmobile tours. In addiiton, locals use snow machines for recreation and to travel from town to town. In 2007, 1,802 snowmobiles were registered on Svalbard.

Aromatic hydrocarbons are a class of chemicals that result from incomplete burning of oil, gas, wood, tobacco, garbage and other organic sources. Treated creosote wood, asphalt and tar also contain the chemicals. They are used in some manufactured products, such as dyes and moth balls.

Industrial factories, power plants, and gas and diesel engines release the pollutants into the environment. Worldwide, engines that burn fossil fuels are a major contributor of the chemical byproducts.

The only studies to date that examine emissions from snowmobiles were done in Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming. Snowmachines there emit carbon monoxide, particulates and organics into the environment. Older models released more pollutants than newer models. (Bishop et al. 2006, Shively et al. 2008).

People are exposed to aromatic hydrocarbons through contaminated air, water and food. The chemicals are of concern because they can affect health. The pollutants are linked to heart disease and cancer. For instance, benzene can damage bone marrow and cause cancer. Toluene and xylene can affect the nervous system.

What did they do?

Scientists measured levels of  aromatic hyrocarbons in the air to determine the contribution of local emissions from snowmobiles, passenger cars and heavy-duty vehicles from a nearby coal mine.

The scientists set up an air monitor at a location near both a main road and a snowmobile track. They collected air samples from mid-April to mid-June, 2007.

Samples were analyzed for benzene, ethyl benzene, toluene and xylene. Results of early spring samples – during the height of snowmobile season – were compared with samples from early summer – after the snow melted – when cars and heavy-duty coal trucks dominate the roads.

Registration records of snowmobiles, cars and high density vehicles were examined to determine how many of each type of vehicle were in the area. Based on the amounts of exhaust emissions each type of vehicle produces, the researchers calculated and compared the contribution of each type of vehicle to the total amount of pollutants measured.

What did they find?

In the spring, when snowmobile season is in full swing, the levels of the chemicals measured near the road are 100 times higher than during the summer, when only cars and vehicles from the coal mine are in use.

An interesting daily pattern was noted in the spring, with sharp peaks in aromatic hydrocarbon levels occurring around 9 a.m. and then again in the afternoon. These peaks correspond with daily snowmobile tours all leaving the town during the morning “rush hour” and then returning later in the afternoon.

Based on knowledge of the amounts of exhaust emissions each type of vehicle produces, the scientists estimate that snowmobiles contribute close to 90 percent of the total aromatic hydrocarbons produced by vehicles in Longyearbyen each year.

More surprisingly, the researchers estimate that snowmobiles with older, less efficient, 2-stroke engines produce more than 90 percent of the total aromatic hydrocarbons snowmobiles generate each year. These older models comprise only 30 percent of the total number of snowmobiles in the community. Basically, the snowmobiles with 2-stroke engines are producing 4 times as much of these pollutants than all other vehicles combined.

What does it mean?

Snowmobiles are a major source of air pollutants called aromatic hydrocarbons in a community in Svalbard located in the Arctic Circle. Older machines produce the majority of the chemicals, which are known to affect human health, during the spring tourist season.

The peak levels of aromatic hydrocarbons in Longyearbyen in the spring are so high that they are close to levels of the same pollutants in Zurich, Switzerland – a major city with close to 400,000 people. As there are only 540 snowmobiles with 2-stroke engines registered in Longyearbyen, it is clear that a small number of snowmobiles can have a big impact on the amount of airborne pollutants.

Although this is startling, it should be noted that the levels of these chemicals in Longyearbyen are well below the federal safety limits as established in the United States. However, vehicular emissions are but one source of exposure to benzene and the other chemicals. Any efforts to lessen exposure to aromatic hydrocarbons can carry potential health benefits.

The good news is that if snowmobiles with 2-stroke engines are targeted for replacement with snowmobiles that have more efficient 4-stroke engines, then levels of aromatic hydrocarbons emitted from vehicles should dramatically decrease during the spring. This may be an attainable goal given the small number of snowmobiles with 2-stroke engines registered in the community.


Resources

Benzene. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Bishop, GA, , DA Burgard, TR Dalton, DH Stedman and JD Ray. 2006. Winter motor-vehicle emissions in Yellowstone National Park. Environmental Science and Technology 40(8): 2505-2510.

The coming of biofuels: study shows reducing gasoline emissions will benefit human health. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratories, US Department of Energy, May 27, 2009.

Mobile Source Emission Pollutants. US Environmental Pollution Agency.

Shively, DD, BMC Pape, RN Mower, Y Zhou, R Russo and BC Sive. 2008. Blowing smoke in Yellowstone: Air quality impacts of oversnow motorized recreation in the park. Environmental Management 41(2):183-199.

Toluene. ToxFAQs. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Control.

Xylene. ToxFAQs. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Control.

 

 

 

outdoor air pollution
More news about
outdoor air pollution